National’s Emerald Club Executive vs. Avis First

I’ve been an AVIS guy as long as I can remember.  Primarily, it’s because my last company had Avis as their designated car rental agency.  When I started my own business twelve years ago, I just carried this loyalty forward.  They have been solid for me and I’ve not questioned my choice.

This year, I’ve decided to step out and try some other programs where it makes sense.  With my Avis First Preferred status, I was able to get a status match with National and now have two rentals under my belt for comparison purposes.

The most obvious learning so far is that it is hard to differentiate your service in this area other than by price.  One of the reasons that I picked National for a trial is that they seem to be right on par with Avis on pricing.  But, both programs make it easy to get to your car without stopping at a counter.  Both programs offer an easy return process and an electronic receipt that appears in your mailbox almost instantly.

Where National tries to differentiate their service is in two areas.

First, and this is the catchy one, when you reach their Emerald aisle, you are not assigned to a particular car as you are with Avis.  Instead, you can look at any car on the aisle and pick the one you want to drive.  How much difference does it make?  I’m not sure.  It’s not like I would show up at my Avis spot and be upset at the car that was selected for me.

Over the past two rentals, I’ve selected a Hyundai Sonata and a Ford pick-up truck.  And, while there were no Porsches or exotic cars on the aisle, it was kind of fun to have options.  Also, when using the Emerald Club Executive status, you reserve a mid-size and the cars on the aisle are full-size.

The second difference from the Avis progam is in the rewards.  With Avis First, the primary reward is a two day weekend rental with every fourth qualifying rental of two or more days.  Honestly, I have never used one of those awards as I have rare occasion to do a weekend rental.

With the Emerald Club, you earn credits for each rental and when you achieve the required number of credits, you earn a free rental day.  Since this day does not have to be a weekend, I’m much more likely to use it.  The number of credits required vary depending on your membership level as follows:

  • Emerald Club – 7
  • Emerald Club Executive – 6
  • Emerald Club Executive Elite – 5

Rental credits are earned as follows:  One credit per qualifying rental or one credit for every four consecutive rental days. Valid for rentals in the US or Canada only. Example: One rental lasts 8 days = 2 credits. One rental lasts 2 days = 1 credit.


One Response to National’s Emerald Club Executive vs. Avis First

  1. Pingback: Q1 Point/Mile Earnings « Note from the Road

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: